Published October 2, 2026 in Deal of the Week

This home asks $140 per square foot. Homes for sale around it are asking $270.

By Brian Caplicki

Real estate, Middletown, NY

That's why it made the list. 171 buyers have already saved it on Zillow. That's 374% more saves than the average of this week's finalists in Middletown, NY. All 171 get an alert the second the price drops or someone else puts in an offer. Right now, you're ahead of all of them.

The numbers

Views on Zillow

Saves on Zillow

Homes analyzed

The home

4 bd · 4 ba · 3,400 sq ft

$ ▬▬▬,▬▬▬

Listed this week. Address: ▬▬ ▬▬▬▬▬ ▬▬

Priceheld backAddressheld back

Text me for the address — (845) 656-4498Opens your messages. No forms. We don't do forms.

In short

$140 per square foot against $270 for homes around it.
Ranked first of 473 active homes scored in Middletown, NY this week.
4 beds, 4 baths, about 3,400 sq ft. Listed this week.
Listings here have been up about 68 days.
Price and address are held back. Text DEAL and they come to you.

Here's what we think happened.

While listed, it earned 171 saves and 1,053 views on Zillow. It ranked first on Zillow saves for the number of days it has been listed.

From the listing: “1870's Farmhouse is set on 6.4 pastoral acres with pond! Original character and detail have been preserved!”

Saves on Zillow · Middletown, NY

1This home171 saves
2Finalist average36 saves

Zillow saves. Finalist average = the mean of this week's finalists in the area, this home included.

What stands out

Gracious entry has lovely curved stairs to 2nd floor!
Sunroom has recessed lights, old, exposed beams and 2 walls of windows to let the sun shine in!
Large DR has door to enclosed porch!

What they saw when they opened the listing.

Map of the approximate area, drawn as a circle rather than a pin — Fig 03.1 · The area

Then they did what you're about to do. They checked the neighborhood.

Asking $/sq ft nearby

The middle asking price per square foot of the homes for sale here now. Asking, not sold.

This home's $/sq ft

This home's own price per square foot, rounded to the nearest $5.

Avg. days listed

The clock every listing in the area is running against.

Active homes

Everything for sale here right now — the full set this pick was scored against.

The math. At $270 per square foot, the median ask nearby, 3,400 square feet would list for $918,000. This one asks less.

Want the address?

It's ready to go. The address, the photos, the numbers behind the numbers.

Text DEAL to (845) 656-4498 Text me

One text and it's yours, usually within the hour. (You're texting me, an actual person. I answer like one.)

What comes back

The address, and the listing it belongs to.
The photos, unblurred, all of them.
The numbers this page is built on, including the ones we would not publish.
A straight answer on whether it is actually right for you — including no.

Not buying right now? You probably know someone who is. Send them this page and be the friend with the good real estate tip.